Jul 14, 2014; Minneapolis, MN, USA; National League outfielder Giancarlo Stanton (27) of the Miami Marlins reacts after failing to hit a home run in the third round during the 2014 Home Run Derby the day before the MLB All Star Game at Target Field. Mandatory Credit: Jesse Johnson-USA TODAY Sports

Marlins Way: Should Stanton Dictate the Marlins Roster?

The Miami Herald had an interesting article yesterday that discussed the likelihood of Stanton bolting Miami if the Marlins do indeed trade Steve Cishek as they are rumored to be exploring. Cishek would certainly bring a decent prospect or two back in a trade, but Clark Spencer cites a major league scout who believes that trading Cishek would seal Giancarlo Stanton‘s fate with Miami.

“I don’t think there’s much chance Stanton ends up staying [long-term] with the Marlins anyway,” the source said. “But if they move Cishek, what’s that telling [Stanton]? If they traded Cishek, they could pretty much kiss him goodbye.”

This prompted a discussion among the writers here at Marlin Maniac as we discussed whether the Marlins should take into account how Stanton might respond to a trade. My belief is that while the Marlins shouldn’t ask him whether or not he approves of a particular move, they still have to be mindful of the message that they are sending Giancarlo. Stanton has made it clear that he is not interested in spending his career playing for a team that is constantly rebuilding.

If I was the GM (and there is no good reason why I shouldn’t be!) than I would hold onto Cishek unless I got a ridiculous offer. If I did make the decision to trade Cishek, I would make sure that I had a deal in the works for Stanton as well, because the longer you wait, the less you get in return.

What would you do? Would you check with Stanton before making any trades? Let us know in the comments below.

Here are some more stories about the Marlins from around the web. 

MLB Trade Deadline: Ian Kennedy, Miami Marlins Trade Target – Fish Stripes

The Miami Marlins saw this weekend that they would definitely need help at starting pitching, and Ian Kennedy of the San Diego Padres might be the perfect candidate.

Miami Marlins’ Anthony DeSclafani called up to provide relief for bullpen – Miami Herald

The Marlins promoted right-hander Anthony DeSclafani on Sunday, less than 12 hours after Miami manager Mike Redmond hinted at bringing up an extra arm to help a “thin bullpen.”

Marlins notes: Sunday gaffes notwithstanding, club showing improvement on bases – Sun Sentinel

Anyone who watched Sunday’s game might have difficulty believing this, but the Marlins are a markedly improved base running team in 2014.

Here at Marlin Maniac

MLB Trade Rumors: Potential Steve Cishek landing spots – Travis Honeycutt

The Marlins most attractive piece that could be moved is Steve Cishek. Travis explores some of the possible destinations for the Marlins closer.

Marlins @ Braves Series Preview: 10 Ridiculous Trade Ideas between Teams – Ehsan Kassim

I got together with Jeff Schafer, the editor of Tomahawk Take, to put together 10 17 ridiculous trade ideas between the two franchises that should provide laughs for our viewers. This is a change-up from our regular series preview chats, but could be just as entertaining, if not more. None of these trades have a realistic shot of happening, but some of them you guys will wish could happen.

Tags: Giancarlo Stanton Miami Marlins

comments powered by Disqus