Sale of the Marlins: Expect Resurrection, Rebuild, or Both?

2 of 3

Is this the end of Gollum, Marlins fans? Mandatory Credit: Steve Mitchell-USA TODAY Sports /

Yesterday morning, a relative bombshell was dropped on the South Florida community when a Forbes report announced that a potential deal was on the table to sell the Miami Marlins. Obviously, that would mean saying goodbye to one Jeffrey Loria, the third and easily longest tenured owner in franchise history. This Sunday will mark fifteen years to the day since the Loria era began, and saying that the experience has been anything approaching smooth sailing would be charitable to the point of delusion.

More from Marlin Maniac

Considering the dizzying heights from which we started- a world championship in just the second year of his tenure- a fall back down to earth was to be expected. But the alacrity with which he turned himself into not just the least popular local owner, but arguably the most reviled owner in professional sports, was as impressive as it was maddening. Loria arrived on the scene at the same time all three other Miami franchises were struggling, as from 2002-2003, the only local team that even tasted the postseason was the Marlins. Just before Spring Training got underway, he even authorized special money to sign Ivan Rodriguez, an All-Star catcher who had earned his trip to Cooperstown before even arriving in Jupiter that February.

Yet, looking back on it all, it feels like he had two strikes on him the moment he got here. Considering the fact that the Expos payroll was always well within $2 million of what the Marlins were spending during Loria’s run with our division rivals to the north, optimism was never really running high at the outset. And then he traded fan favorites Ryan Dempster and Cliff Floyd, while at the same time, former penny pinching owner John Henry suddenly seemed to have a lot more money to spend up in Boston. If anything, that feeling of disappointment that came from a second new owner not immediately breaking the bank on payroll counted against him as much as anything that had been reported from his Montreal days.

Then 2003 was in the rearview mirror, and the cavalcade of missteps began. Low payrolls. Firesales. Stadium deals. Fans had a litany of grievances, both real and imagined. Even when they do stuff right, fault is found. When the Marlins do something wrong, the nation chortles. The franchise is a punchline, except for the moments genuine sorrow is expressed on the part of our baseball betters in twenty-nine other markets and by at least one other entertainment and sports programming network. Rightly or wrongly, all of that goes back to one Jeffrey Loria.

Who now just might be on the verge of leaving. For good. Never to return again.

Basically, I’ve had that scene where Smeagol tells Gollum to “go away and never come back” playing on a loop in my head since lunch yesterday.

And yes, I’m aware I’ve just painted all Marlins fans as Smeagol in this analogy. I’m actually pretty comfortable with it. Gollum did a lot of messed up stuff, but he also got us a ring and a stadium.

Still though, this is something I’ve dreamed about since 2002. If the pockets end up being deep, it’ll be something I’ve dreamed about since 1998. A kinder, gentler George Steinbrenner coming down to the tropics and creating a perennial dynasty. Outspending the bulk of the league in international scouting, nestled comfortably in the most exciting city in the most exciting state not to charge income tax, the Marlins essentially become the next St. Louis Cardinals.

Just without the cybercrime.

Honestly, they don’t even have to win a title. I have crystal clear memories of watching my team win two world championships. Only eight teams have done that while I’ve been alive, and only five since 1990. Eleven teams haven’t even won a title, ever. But being able to consistently rely on being in the race, having a real chance, producing winning seasons, and allowing myself to fall for players without seeing them traded at the height of their powers? That’s what I want to see, and ideally before I have kids that I have to pass this fandom on to.

Assuming this does go through, and you have to think that Major League Baseball would be willing to be a bit more flexible than usual on liquid assets to get this guy out of the picture, the big question is what should we expect to happen? Will this be our Independence Day, a return to middle of the pack salaries, and pursuing the best free-agents? Or do all the sins of the past get expunged with a new owner, allowing them the freedom of a Cubs style rebuild?

Ultimately, on you to decide. But here’s two sides to the story of what to expect from the Good Ship Marlins in 2018 if franchise owner No. 4 is at the helm.

He’s pretty. Maybe the new Marlins owner will buy him for us. Mandatory Credit: Ken Blaze-USA TODAY Sports /

Marlins Scenario No. 1: Twenty CCs of Cash- Stat

Twenty million dollars. Throw that on top of the current payroll projection for 2017, and you will be just about at the MLB average payroll. Seems like a reasonable request for anyone looking to repair an organization’s relationship with their city, and to boost attendance in a newly acquired ballpark. Salary inflation would eat into some of that, but even that small of an uptick makes landing a bonafide No. 1 or No. 2 caliber free-agent starting pitcher a real possibility.

And that’s the type of move a new owner would have to take. Immediately erase any association with the practices of the past. Putting aside the possibility that the next owner just wants to make bank Loria style, expect money to be spent adding on the existing corp of young talent. Even if some of those pieces lose some luster this season, you can be sure that after trading them for MLB ready talent, money will be spent on proven MLB ready replacements. Basically, if the Marlins move Marcell Ozuna to get that young pitcher they need, you can be sure it’s because they have just signed Carlos Gonzalez, J.D. Martinez, or Andrew McCutcheon. Or at least Jayson Werth‘s beard.

That seems to be the expectation of many a Marlins fan, and many more pundits. Trading players is fine, just so long as you pay for replacements or make upgrades elsewhere if a young prospect is ready to go. It’s even a reasonable one.

What’s more, when stacked against the club’s history, it’s an essential one. If those turnstiles are going to see more people push past them then any of the previous fifteen seasons have, it will take more than a name change at the ownership level. It will take some semblance of the ownership level actually caring about what the fans think.

That pretty much starts, and ends, with a willingness to try as much as the average team to win. Consider 2004, when the Marlins were defending that second world championship. They launched their title defense with a payroll war chest smaller than twenty-five other teams. Put in even starker terms, in a year where the average payroll was just over $68 million, Loria spent $42 million. The Fish spend just the average that year, and they probably have both Pudge and Derrek Lee back with team. Thinking about what could have been in that season, or a handful of others, if just that average payroll had been spent is enough to keep fans up at night.

Doing just that much, consistently, would win back many a fan who swore off the team.

Marlins Scenario No. 2: The Trendy Rebuild

As has been pointed out multiple times since 2014, the Marlins farm system isn’t exactly awesome. Last year’s first round pick Braxton Garrett is the only player projected with a reasonable amount of confidence to one day be relevant, with a wide gap between him and the rest of Top 10 tier talent. Shortsighted trades are responsible for the most part, but so is the propensity to promote young talent early under the Loria regime. That last bit has been a staple of the organization since 2003, with the arrival of Miguel Cabrera and Dontrelle Willis.

Make no mistake though, the odds of anyone in this system stepping up to make a major impact this year or next are long at best. The foundation that the third Marlins playoff team will be built on are either already in the majors, in another team’s farm system, or yet to be drafted.

Which means if the 2017 Marlins fail to take a major step forward, the new owner might feel the time has come to clean house entirely.

It would be the nuclear option, one that has become more popular throughout the league over the last few years, even if the success rate of it hasn’t been nearly as clearly established. There’s plenty of talent that would fetch a handsome return- Stanton, Ozuna, Christian Yelich, J.T. Realmuto all come to mind. The rebuilt bullpen could be partly scavenged, especially if a sale takes place before the Trade Deadline, and the team is struggling.

This scenario is entirely dependent upon the new owner betting heavily upon the hatred of Loria running so deep in South Florida that the new guy would get full benefit of the doubt that this was a temporary measure. That the plan was to do it the Cubs way, stockpiling young superstar talent while pairing it the right mix of high value, high cost veterans.

Honestly, it is a possibility. More honestly still, one I want to see happen if this team posts a losing season. At least in part.

Next: Are Fish Being Sold?

But my money is on the bottom line being about money. Whomever ends up buying this team won’t be willing to burn through the honeymoon phase out of the gate by asking fans to believe a team with a history of bad draft and trade choices will suddenly get them all right.

Dare to dream Marlins fans. That could just be a light at the end of the tunnel.

Or it could just be the glare from the Home Run Sculpture.

Home / Marlins News

More from Marlin Maniac

Schedule