Miami Marlins TD aftermath: 3 biggest winners

3 of 3

The trade deadline came and went and it’s time to see how it went for our Miami Marlins. The full trade deadline analysis can be found here. I also covered the trade deadline for The Fish in part 1 and part 2 teams stand out as the biggest winners of the trade deadline and it’s important to see how that affects The Fish. The list is in no particular order. Let’s begin the list!

The Miami Marlins may not have won the trade deadline.

1. NEW YORK YANKEES

OAKLAND, CALIFORNIA – JULY 21: Frankie Montas #47 of the Oakland Athletics pitches against the Detroit Tigers during game two of a doubleheader at RingCentral Coliseum on July 21, 2022 in Oakland, California. (Photo by Lachlan Cunningham/Getty Images) /

The top World Series contenders this season didn’t disappoint. The Bronx Bombers needed an ace and got one in Frankie Montas from the Oakland Athletics. This was a great trade for them as now they’re going to be running out a rotation led by Gerrit Cole, Nestor Cortes and the aforementioned Frankie Montas.

The New York Yankees were already busy prior to the deadline as well, acquiring LF Andrew Benintendi for his contact. This was accentuated at the trade deadline, as the Bronx Bombers shopped struggling and benched OF Joey Gallo to the Los Angeles Dodgers. Gallo is batting .159/.282/.339 in 82 games and 233 AB’s.

The New York Yankees weren’t done, as they also upgraded their bullpen in two separate deals (with one including Frankie Montas), acquiring Scott Effross from the Chicago Cubs and Lou Trivino from the Oakland Athletics. Trivino has a ghastly 6.47 ERA, but also has a 3.83 FIP and a healthy 12.7 K/9 to go with it. Bad luck surely led to Trivino’s struggles this season.

The New York Yankees then made a surprise swap, by landing hometown boy CF Harrison Bader from the St. Louis Cardinals for SP Jordan Montgomery. This was a move that was highly criticized on Twitter, but made perfect sense for the New York Yankees, Bader is an elite defensive CF, which is exactly what The Bronx Bombers need. Montgomery was just an inning-eater, who has a 3.69 ERA/3.91 FIP with 7.6 K/9 and 1.2 BB/9. He was honestly pretty replaceable.

The Miami Marlins will hopefully be in a position to do similar things, when we’re a contending team as well. The Bronx Bombers improved their rotation, bullpen and defense, which were all the areas that they needed to improve.

2. HOUSTON ASTROS

HOUSTON, TEXAS – AUGUST 02: Trey Mancini #26 of the Houston Astros pinch hits in the ninth inning against the Boston Red Sox at Minute Maid Park on August 02, 2022 in Houston, Texas. (Photo by Bob Levey/Getty Images) /

The other top American League team didn’t disappoint either. The Houston Astros needed to keep pace with the New York Yankees and they did just that. Their biggest needs were the bullpen, catcher and first base and they focused on improving all of those areas. This type of proactive behavior is something that the Miami Marlins need to have when the time comes as well.

The Miami Marlins need to learn to fill all of their areas of need in the same way.

The one swap that stands out to me is Houston dealing from their starting pitching surplus. Houston did so by trading starting pitcher Jake Odorizzi to the Atlanta Braves for relief pitcher Will Smith. This was a swap based entirely on filling each other’s needs. Atlanta improved their starting pitching depth and Houston improved their bullpen.

The Houston Astros then looked to upgrade at catcher over Martín Maldonado, the veteran catcher is batting .173/.238/.337 in 79 games and 243 AB’s. He does have a 0.3 dWAR but the offense was simply not worth it. Houston acquired Christian Vázquez from the Boston Red Sox. Christian is batting .282/.327/.432 with a 0.9 dWAR. He was clearly an upgrade.

The Houston Astros then filled their hole at first base, or at least gave themselves an alternative. Incumbent starter Yuli Gurriel has been a disaster this season, batting .246/.295/.394 in 96 games and 350 AB’s. Houston needed an upgrade and got one in Trey Mancini from the Baltimore Orioles. Mancini is batting .268/.347/.404 in 92 games and 354 AB’s. He’s clearly an upgrade over Gurriel.

The Houston Astros upgraded their weak areas and are now right up there with the New York Yankees for a shot at the AL pennant. Why couldn’t the Miami MRlins do something like this in 2004 or 2005? Or even 2009?

3. SAN DIEGO PADRES

WASHINGTON, DC – AUGUST 14: Juan Soto #22 of the Washington Nationals bats against the Atlanta Braves at Nationals Park on August 14, 2021 in Washington, DC. (Photo by G Fiume/Getty Images) /

This list is in no particular order, but if there was an order, I think it’s pretty clear which team would have ended up in first place. The San Diego Padres did a monumental blockbuster to accentuate what was already a great trade deadline.

Let’s start with what they did closer to the deadline however… They locked up ace starting pitcher Joe Musgrove for 5 years/$100 million. Musgrove was on his way to being the most in-demand starting pitcher on the upcoming free agent market, but now he will stay in San Diego long-term instead. The Miami Marlins did something similar and for less money, when we locked up ace Sandy Alcantara last off-season for 5 years/$55 million.

The San Diego Padres finally shed the bad contract of 1B Eric Hosmer, shipping him to the Boston Red Sox for a lottery ticket prospect. They will however have to pay most of his salary, which is a bit of an issue. Ironically, I suggested this swap for the Miami Marlins before.

Let’s now turn to the blockbuster trade that rocked the trade deadline. The San Diego Padres acquired RF Juan Soto from the Washington Nationals. Not just Soto, but 1B Josh Bell as well. Bell is having a career year, batting .301/.384/.493 in 103 games and 375 AB’s. He’s a massive upgrade over Hosmer, who is batting .272/.336/.391 in 90 games and 335 AB’s. They traded Luke Voit as well, with the DH batting .225/.317/.416 in 82 games and 298 AB’s.

Juan Soto is a future Hall of Famer at his current career pace and so it was a stunner that it was the San Diego Padres that acquired him. The once overlooked team are now major players on the trade and free agency markets, pairing Soto up with SS Fernando Tatis Jr., recently signed to a 14 year/$340 million extension, and 3B Manny Machado, signed for 10 years and $300 million in free agency.

Having Soto, Tatis and Machado in the middle of the batting order is truly spectacular. San Diego did of course empty out their farm on a way, and will likely trade Soto before he hits free agency, but this is an amazing win-now move.

The Miami Marlins can learn a lot from these teams. The San Diego Padres in particular have been a small to mid-market team not known for spending, and then went all-out in the last few years. There’s no reason why The Fish playing in a big market can’t do the same. If not, we need new ownership.

Related Story. What if we hired him as our next manager?. light

Home / Marlins News

The Miami Marlins may not have won the trade deadline.

The Miami Marlins need to learn to fill all of their areas of need in the same way.

Schedule