Miami Marlins must get to a point where they can get those one-year wonders

With so many talented players signing one-year deals this winter, it just serves as a reminder that Miami must become a desired destination in MLB.
Pittsburgh Pirates v Miami Marlins
Pittsburgh Pirates v Miami Marlins | Megan Briggs/GettyImages

Another MLB offseason, another instance of the Miami Marlins protesting to anyone who will listen that they do spend money.

Ooodles of it, if you must know. Just not on, you know, MLB payroll.

Now, none of this is to say that every penny the Miami Marlins have put into their off-the-field infrastructure the past few years hasn't been essential. If you don't have the resources to buy your way out of trouble in free agency, and to afford to be able to swing and miss on a big contract, you need to be really good at making sure you maximize the talent you do have. Drafting and developing the best you can, not just cutting the biggest check.

Yet that doesn't mean that it doesn't hurt for Marlins fans seeing quality player after quality player sign affordable one and two-year deals elsewhere, in some cases for inferior teams.

Luis Arraez. Nick Castellanos. Ty France. Munetaka Murakami. Ryan O'Hearn. Eugenio Suarez. Nearly all of them took way less than expected heading into the offseason, with only France's contract being truly as low as anticipated. How much better would Marlins fans feel about their already promising roster with just one more of these proven bats helping to fill out the order as opposed to say, Christopher Morel?

Obviously, the answer to that question is a lot. Oodles better, in fact.

As mentioned in a piece the other day, part of Miami's decisions in this department this winter come down to really believing they can squeeze more value out of what they have than some of these names mentioned above. Yet part of that calculus is about the dollar amount attached to those names, and how Marlins prices just aren't the same as the prices other clubs get to pay for these short-term players looking to prove themselves. Especially the above-average one-year wonders.

The Tim Andersons and Chris Paddacks of the world? Teams like the Marlins can get those in spades. Players who have already massively declined and are looking to prove they belong in the majors, period. But players who keep pulling off the trick of being good, outpeforming expected stats and/or looking to prove themselves worthy of a big money deal? Players still in their primes that for whatever the reason just became a free agent at the exact wrong time?

Miami continues to struggle to be able to land that caliber of free agent, finding players either completely unwilling to accept being sentenced to a season in loanDepot Park or demanding a king's ransom for enduring such a fate.

For make no mistake, with the possible exception of Arraez (who is publicly on record as having liked being in Miami), every last one of those free agent prices that have irked you this offseason was not the price the Marlins were going to have to pay to get said player. Part of it is about how the ballpark plays. Part of it is about the frequent emptiness of said park relative to other teams. Part of it is about continued perception about the team's willingness to do what it takes to contend. Undoubtedly, some of it has even been about some of those facilities the Marlins have put so much money into refurbishing.

This has to change if the Marlins are ever going to get to their dream of consistently competing.

Drafting and developing is, of course, the key. There's not much the Marlins can do about not playing home games in Coors Field, PNC Park, or one of the other gems of the sport. Making Miami a desirable destination in every other way, though, so that they can leverage South Florida's beaches and Florida's lack of income tax in a way the regions other pro sports teams can? That's entirely in the club's control.

If these new features of the organization are truly as awesome as advertised, word will spread amongst the MLBPA. Eventually, those results will bear fruit on the playing field too. Glimpses can be seen already. Ultimately, it's all about the winning. There's not a team in baseball in more dire need of back to back winning seasons.

However, just a little more spending could a long way towards speeding up that timetable. Not being able to be perennially panned for having the lowest payroll in the majors will do wonders not just for ticket sales, but for moving the Marlins up free agents call sheets as well.

Once all this happens? Those one-year wonders will be willing to give Miami a fair price.

Until then? The club will continue to have an even harder time than need be to compete with the bigger spenders out there.

Loading recommendations... Please wait while we load personalized content recommendations