Shea Langeliers
Langeliers has a slight advantage over Melendez with a 29% thrown out rate on stolen base attempts and he is on the tanking Oakland Athletics. He has hit 7 home runs and driven in 23 on a pathetic Oakland team so you have to imagine his stats will excel on the Marlins and his slash line stands at .207/.280/.384 with an OPS of .664. Langeliers is also a young catcher and the Marlins might not be as high on him or Melendez due to that fact.