Miami Marlins: Grading the Jazz Chisholm for Agustin Ramirez Blockbuster Trade

The Miami Marlins' biggest move of their busy 2024 trade deadline was a deal that sent franchise star Jazz Chisholm to the New York Yankees. Any deal involving an All-Star-level player will surely draw ire from at least one fan base. However, there is a particular nuance that makes the Chisholm trade particularly difficult to grade.

How did the Marlins fair in this blockbuster? Let's look at the important factors.

Factor #1: The Superstar

Say what you want about Jazz. While he often seems to get labeled as a poor clubhouse presence or a player with character concerns, his on-field production cannot be ignored. Jazz has elite speed. He has plus power, particularly for a middle infielder or centerfielder. And he has played competent defense at three positions this season.

Chisholm also seems to be rounding into his prime. His previous career high in homers was 19 in 2023, his best stolen base season came in 2021 when he swiped 23 bags, and his best batting season was in 2022 when he posted a .254 average.

In 416 at-bats this season, Jazz has already set a new career-high in steals with 24 (with no signs of slowing down). His 17 homers and .252 average are also on the cusp of all-time highs.

If his current pace continues, a 30-hander 40-steal season could be in the cards. For context, only 21 players in MLB history have ever reached this mark.

There is no doubt that Miami traded a player with the potential to be a generational talent. This brings us to...