MLB.com recently published a poll from MLB front office executives. One question, about prospects with defensive upside, identified Miami Marlins shortstop Starlyn Caba as having the 2nd highest defensive ceiling.
Caba, who was the headline prospect in the recent Jesus Luzardo trade, has a fascinating profile. He has a solid hit tool (he currently has a 55 grade on a scale of 20-to-80 and a .252 batting average in the minor leagues).
Caba's athleticism and sharp batting eye were also on display as he paced the Rookie-level Florida Complex League in walks (52), steals (37), and runs (44). Unfortunately, his lack of power gives him almost no home run upside. Otherwise, Caba has strong tools
However, Caba's true value comes from his 70-grade fielding ability. Heralded as one of the top defenders in his class, the new Marlin's glove work has drawn comparisons to Mets' superstar Fransisco Lindor.
If his defense translates as expected, Caba will be a legitimate long-term option as a starter for Miami. He has the upside to produce at an Andrelton Simmons. He has a lane to be for Miami what Brandon Crawford was to San Fransisco or Dansby Swanson has been to Atlanta and Chicago (minus the pop).
While his power limitations will likely cap his star potential, his agility, speed, glovework, and IQ will make a massive impact at a premium position. It would be shocking if Caba failed to become a perennial top finisher for MLB's Gold Glove award. If I had to bet an amount of money that mattered to me, I'd wager that the Marlins' shortstop wins at least one defensive award in his career.
As a floor, he will compare to players like Mauricio Dubón, Ha-seong Kim, or Luis Guillorme. At his peak, he will bring Platinum Glove upside, a high OBP, and solid production on the base paths. I continue to believe this was a slam-dunk trade for Peter Bendix and the Miami Marlins.